How Much Contingency Should a Renovation Budget Hold?
A practical way to size a renovation contingency by project type, age of the house and how much demolition is involved.
The contingency line is the part of a renovation budget everyone agrees they need and almost nobody sizes properly. Ten percent is the number that gets repeated, but it is a rule of thumb, not a rule. On a like-for-like bathroom refresh in a house you know well, ten percent may be generous. On a first renovation in a seventy-year-old house where walls will be opened, it is usually not enough.
Watch: 5 Renovation Budget Lines You're Forgetting (2 min)
A short visual walkthrough of the five lines every budget needs — materials, labour, allowances, fees & services and contingency. Captions are built into the video; no sign-up needed.
Why 10% is not a rule
Contingency exists to pay for things you could not see at quote time, not for things you forgot to put in the scope. Those are different problems. A missing line item is a planning error and should be added to the budget before you start; contingency is for rot behind the tile, a subfloor that needs levelling, or a panel that no longer meets code once it is touched.
So start by making the scope complete, then size the buffer against uncertainty, not against the total. A $40,000 kitchen with all appliances chosen and walls staying put carries less uncertainty than a $15,000 bathroom where the layout might move.
Risk factors that raise the buffer
- Age of the house. Anything built before the 1980s has a higher chance of outdated wiring, plumbing or insulation once a wall is opened.
- How much demolition is involved. Opening walls, lifting floors or moving plumbing multiplies the number of unknowns. Surface-only work does not.
- Wet rooms and structural changes. Bathrooms, kitchens and any load-bearing alteration concentrate several trades in a small space, so one surprise delays all of them.
- Decision completeness. If finishes, fixtures or layouts are still unresolved at the start, add buffer for the change orders those decisions will produce.
- Permits and inspections. Work that requires an inspection can be brought to a halt by a correction you cannot schedule around.
A practical way to use this list: start at 10 percent for low-uncertainty work, move to 15 percent for a typical first renovation, and treat 20 percent as reasonable when the house is old, the demolition is extensive, or decisions are still open. Very large projects can taper the percentage because the absolute amount is already substantial — but the risk factors still apply room by room.
Where to hold the money
Keep it separate from the working budget, both in the spreadsheet and in the account. If the contingency is folded into line items, it gets spent on upgrades before the first surprise arrives. It should not be used to justify a better tile, a larger appliance package or a scope addition you simply wanted.
It is also worth agreeing in writing with your contractor how contingency is authorised. A clear rule — for example, any draw above a fixed amount requires your approval with the reason written down — prevents the buffer from disappearing into small, undocumented extras.
When to release it
Do not spend the contingency early and do not release all of it at the end. The risk is front-loaded: most hidden problems appear during demolition and rough-in. Once walls are closed, inspected and dried in, uncertainty drops sharply. A sensible pattern is to hold the full amount until rough-in is signed off, release roughly half of what remains at that point, and keep a smaller reserve through to the punch list for finish damage and final adjustments.
Anything left over is not a windfall to be absorbed; it is money the project did not need. Track it as a separate line so you can see which risk assumptions were too pessimistic — that record makes the next project's budget considerably more accurate.
The free calculators on this site keep the working budget and the contingency as separate lines, and the spreadsheet bundles below are the ones we use to log each draw against a reason. Neither replaces a licensed contractor where one is required, but both make it much harder to discover in week six that the buffer was already spent.
Related reading
- Room-by-room renovation costs and a free calculator
- Where a kitchen budget actually goes
- A realistic timeline for a first renovation
- The right order to renovate a house
- Five renovation budget lines you're forgetting
- How to compare contractor quotes
Do the whole renovation on one spreadsheet
If you would rather work in Excel than in ten browser tabs, these are the sheets behind the calculators on this site.
Keep the money side in one workbook
Renovation budgets or client invoices, the problem is the same: you need to see what you billed, what you actually collected and what you set aside. A 7-sheet Excel workbook that does it offline, with no macros.